Skip to main content

“Francly” the Wrong Move

By
Image: 123rf
Two months ago, the Swiss National Bank (SNB) unexpectedly abandoned the Swiss Franc’s exchange-rate peg to the Euro. The move rocked financial markets, and the value of the Swissie, as the Franc is known, soared the most in its trading history. The Economist quoted an analyst describing the Franc’s dizzying rise as a “20-plus-standard-deviation move,” something that should only happen once in “many squillions of years.” The decision by the SNB to remove the peg was unwise. Its ramifications will, and are, being felt by the Swiss economy.

In 2011, as the European debt crisis deepened, the SNB implemented a currency peg, tying the Franc’s value to that of the Euro. This was because the Swiss currency, seen as secure, saw massive inflows from investors searching for a “safe haven.” As Euros were sold and Francs were bought, the latter’s value rose dramatically. Switzerland, dependent on exports for some 70% of GDP, saw its competitiveness decrease. Due to the stronger Franc, it became more difficult for foreigners to buy Swiss products. In order to drive down the value of the Franc to a more suitable level, the SNB started printing Francs and buying Euros with the newly minted currency. This was a twofold measure, increasing demand for Euros whilst also increasing the supply of Francs. The overall effect counteracted the demand that had been driving the Franc’s value higher. 

Why did the SNB abandon the peg? There are various theories. Many in Switzerland were angered by the rate at which the Bank was printing Francs. Some said the increase in money supply could lead to excessive inflation. Those concerns are groundless: Switzerland has too little inflation, not too much. Another plausible reason is that the European Central Bank’s planned “Quantitative Easing”, QE for short, would make it increasingly difficult to maintain the peg. QE entails stimulating the economy through bond buying programs, essentially pumping money into the economy as assets are bought up. The resulting flood of Euros would devalue the currency, making it even harder for the SNB to prevent the Franc from appreciating. 

Whilst unpegging the Franc, the SNB attempted to strike a balance by simultaneously slashing deposit rates to negative 0.75 percent. Cutting interest rates on deposits held in a particularly currency should, in theory, reduce investor interest in that currency, instead encouraging them to seek better returns in other currencies. However, the dampening effect of the interest rate slash could not prevent the Franc’s massive rise.  

Regardless of the SNB’s thinking, the currency maneuver raises many concerns. The immediate fallout was felt by foreign exchange (FX) brokers and FX trading desks. FXCM, an American retail brokerage offering leveraged foreign currency trading, suffered losses large enough that it required an emergency bailout. Deutsche Bank, Citigroup, and Barclays lost a combined USD 400 million. 

The effects on the broader economy are even more worrying. On March 19, the SNB will be a giving its first policy outlook since the Franc’s cap was removed, and it is expected that the state of the economy will have weakened. Switzerland’s economy, propelled by tourism and exports, will come under immense stress. As the Franc appreciates, Switzerland’s exports become more expensive and therefore less attractive to foreign buyers. Tourism, such as visits to Switzerland’s famed ski resorts, becomes much more costly with the steep rise in the Franc’s value. The knock on effect from a slowdown in these two critical sectors will be felt throughout the Swiss economy, with likely results being a diminished growth rate, higher unemployment, and stagnant wage growth. The probable chill in the economy and wage growth risks exacerbating deflationary forces in Switzerland. Deflation will further drag on the economy, as consumers delay spending in the anticipation of even lower prices in the future. 

It is to be seen just how large an impact the SNB’s move to remove the cap creates. However, it is clear that its decision has potentially put Switzerland on a path of deflation and economic stagnation. 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

On Myanmar

By
This is adapted from a paper I wrote for my Comparative Politics class at Harvard . A Friendless People Thousands have been killed. Hundreds of thousands have fled. They are a people without a home, much less a state. Such is the plight of the Rohingya, whom a UN spokesperson once called the most friendless people in the world. The United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights has called the situation a “textbook example of ethnic cleansing” (“UN”). This latest wave of state-sponsored violence follows a series of attacks by militants—a small insurgent group, the Arakan Rohingya Salvation Army (ARSA)—in August on Myanmarese military outposts. The brutal military crackdown is ostensibly targeted at insurgents. Yet, it is unmistakably civilians who are bearing the brunt of the violence, with the UN High Commissioner calling the response “clearly disproportionate” and “without regard for basic principles of international law” (“UN”). The approach of ethnic institutionalism has
Post a Comment
Read more

The Tax Reform India Needs

By
Image: Tizi A version of this article also appeared in the South China Morning Post's Young Post on Thursday, May 5.  http://yp.scmp.com/news/features/article/103398/india%E2%80%99s-economy-taking-right-steps-goods-and-service-tax India’s current prime minister, Narendra Modi, was elected in 2014 on his economic credentials and the promise that he would bring to the nation the same prosperity he brought, as chief minister, to his home state of Gujarat.  The keystone of Modi’s economic policy is a nationwide goods-and-service tax (GST), intended to streamline the myriad state and central-government levies currently encumbering business in the country.   Under the prevailing tax regime, multiple layers of tax are imposed on the same good, and interstate trade is complicated by varying tax rates between states. Transporting goods across state borders can entail long waiting times to resolve tax matters, and the plethora of obscure charges leaves ample room for co
1 comment
Read more

Where Lurks the Next Crisis?

By
Photo: SCMP Optimism flows freely through the markets today. Asset prices are at record highs: investors are happier than ever to throw money at barely profitable technology companies, debt issuances from dubious companies and volatile governments, and anything blockchain related—from Bitcoin to Ethereum to Insanecoin, which does actually exist.     Most observers think that the coin mania is a bubble waiting to burst. But bears have been calling the whole market a bubble for a while, predicting an end to the years-long economic recovery and stock market boom. The old joke goes that economists have called seven of the last two recessions. It still rings true. Doomsayers have been convinced of a market crash since the post-recession recovery had barely gotten on its legs. But with things as they are today, are we on a path toward crisis?   I will not engage in the perilous business of trying to predict when the next economic downturn or market tumble will occur. Any such p
Post a Comment
Read more